Beyond the tug-of-war: Navigating school change through curiosity

When new school initiatives meet resistance, the instinct is often to push harder—but pressure only breeds defence. Discover how shifting from persuasion to curiosity can transform change fatigue into meaningful engagement.
Share

Have you ever noticed what happens in a game of tug-of-war? The harder one side pulls, the more the other side leans back and holds firm.

Change conversations in schools can feel the same. A new initiative is introduced. Concerns are raised. Someone says, “This won’t work.”

The instinct is often to respond with more explanation, more reassurance, more persuasion.

But the harder we push, the more people tend to resist. Not because they’re difficult. But because pressure creates defence.

What looks like resistance is often information. Concerns about workload, student needs, past experiences, or competing priorities are often sitting underneath it.

Most change doesn’t stall because people lack information. It stalls because they haven’t connected with their own reason to change.

That’s where Motivational Interviewing shifts the approach. Instead of convincing, it invites curiosity. Instead of pushing, it creates space. And it turns resistance into something to understand, not overcome.

The question becomes less, “How do I get people on board?” And more, “What matters to them here?”

Here are three simple language shifts you can put into practice straight away.

Here’s what we’ve learned:

  • Instead of “You need to change,” try, “What’s your perspective on what’s happening?”
  • Instead of focusing on what needs to change, explore, “What’s working well about how you’re currently doing this?”
  • Instead of “This is non-negotiable,” explore, “What matters most to you about this?”

These small shifts move conversations from resistance to reflection. They invite people into the process rather than positioning them as passive recipients of it.

This isn’t soft leadership. It’s effective leadership.

When people feel heard and respected, they engage differently. They move from defending their position to exploring possibilities. They contribute ideas instead of withdrawing. They commit because they see value, not because they’re complying.

In a context of burnout, workforce shortages, and change fatigue, leaders need approaches that build trust and sustain relationships, not more pressure.

Motivational Interviewing offers exactly that: a way of working with resistance rather than against it.

Because resistance isn’t always a barrier. Sometimes, it’s the doorway to what people need in order to move forward.

How we can help

Want to go deeper? Our Trauma-Informed Leadership training teaches you the full toolkit: evidence-based strategies for building trust, navigating challenging conversations, and creating cultures where people actually want to engage.

Ready to explore this for your school? Schedule a call with our team below. We’d love to support your team in building a resilient and humane workplace.

Ready to take the next step? Connect with our team today

PREVIOUS ARTICLES
Trauma-Informed Practice

Behaviour as communication: A trauma-informed approach

Trauma-Informed Practice

Why school culture depends on co-regulation